| Name | Reviewer | Quote | Score |
| QuandaryLand.com (PC) | Rosemary Young | SafeCracker really is quite an enjoyable game and there is some challenge in accessing and opening every single safe. | N/A |
| The Adrenaline Vault (PC) | Bob Mandel | Safecracker is a pure puzzle offering, as there is virtually no adventure here, with more similarity in gameplay to Microsoft's Pandora's Box. | 2.5 out of 5 |
| IGN.com (PC) | Scott Steinberg | One of the hardest adventure titles I've ever seen, Nut, er...Safecracker is a challenge worthy of the most demanding gamer. | 5.2 out of 10 |
| Murray Peterson (PC) | Murray Peterson | It may not be a great game, but puzzle enthusiasts will likely enjoy it. | N/A |
| Applelinks.com (PC) | Kirk Hiner | Although Safecracker won't make you stand up cheer, there's also really nothing about which to complain...unless you're easily frustrated, that is. | 3.0 out of 5 |